Postgraduate supervision differs by level. Masters students need mapped routes and checkpoints; doctoral candidates must own the map. Here is how to run both.
Masters students and doctoral candidates are different working relationships, and most supervisors learn this early. The masters student needs a mapped route and steady checkpoints. The doctoral candidate needs to own the map and tolerate long stretches without you. Confusing the two is where supervision goes wrong, and it shows up as stalled chapters, missed milestones or a thesis that never lands. This guide lays out the real difference and how to run it.
With that difference in view, Thesis Studio is Lectimax's module for supervision at cohort and portfolio scale. It gives you a shared view of every student's milestones so you can keep each relationship distinct. You define what a milestone means and what good looks like.
What does a masters supervision look like?
Start with the masters student, whose supervision is for most of the year a structured project with a deadline. The student has a defined scope, a research question you helped narrow, and a schedule with hard checkpoints. Your job is to keep them moving through a route someone else has walked. You set the milestones, you check the drafts, and you intervene early because the window is short. A masters thesis demonstrates that the student can complete a piece of research to a standard, and nobody expects them to define a research programme from nothing.
The practical consequence is that you meet often and you set the agenda. A masters student who disappears for three weeks has usually stalled, and the cost of recovering is high near a deadline. Regular, short check ins beat occasional long ones.
What changes when the student is a doctoral candidate?
The relationship inverts once the student is a doctoral candidate, because they are training to become an independent researcher. The student is meant to define the problem, choose the method and carry the project, so your role is to interrogate and leave the driving to them. You push back on a weak research question and leave the fixing to the student. You ask what the literature says and do not tell them. The pace is slower and the milestones are coarser, because the work is about depth and originality that cannot be scheduled in weeks.
Independence still leaves room for you. Doctoral candidates need a different kind of supervisor, one who acts as a critical reader and a gatekeeper of standards and who can mostly set aside the project manager role. The hardest part is knowing when to let a student fail small, so they learn before the committee finds the flaw.
Where do the milestones differ?
This difference in role shows up directly in the milestones. Masters milestones are short and mechanical. They run from proposal to ethics to first chapter to draft to final, and each one is a gate you can check with a rubric in a few minutes. Doctoral milestones are fewer and weightier. They are a defensible research question, a complete literature map, a method that survives scrutiny and a draft that stands up to an examiner. Each of those is itself a project.
What a milestone means also differs between the two levels. For a masters student a passed milestone means the route is still open. For a doctoral candidate a passed milestone means the research question has survived your best attempt to break it, which is a much higher bar.
How much independence should each level carry?
That higher bar brings us to independence. Masters students get limited independence within a clear frame. You choose the feasible scope, you approve the method and you set the pace, and you intervene the moment the work drifts. Too much freedom at this level produces a diffuse thesis and a panicked student. Doctoral candidates get wide independence inside a firm standard. You hold the quality bar and the rigour of the argument, while the student owns the choices, the setbacks and the timetable. The PhD is the last time someone is graded on a long piece of work, and it works best when the student is the one steering.
Getting the level wrong cuts both ways. Supervise a masters student like a doctoral candidate and you will carry a thesis that collapses at the deadline. Supervise a doctoral candidate like a masters student and you train someone who cannot work alone, which is the one outcome the degree is meant to rule out.
How do you run both across a whole cohort?
Applying these distinctions gets harder when the difficulty is twenty students at different stages at once. Each needs a different kind of attention, and the memory of who is due what stops being reliable around the fifth student. The answer is a shared, current picture of every milestone in place of a stack of individual diaries. When you can see the whole cohort at a glance, you notice the masters student who has not moved and the doctoral candidate who is quietly stuck on a method. You can then direct your attention where it matters.
You still make the calls. A cohort view keeps every student's state in one place and turns supervision from a set of private conversations into a portfolio you can actually run.
FAQ
Do masters and PhD students need different checklists? Yes, and the difference is the pace and the bar. Masters milestones are short gates on a fixed route, and doctoral milestones are heavier and define the research itself.
Can the same supervision habit cover both? The rituals overlap, but the centre of gravity does not. Meet a masters student to keep them moving, and meet a doctoral candidate to interrogate their thinking.
Is Thesis Studio a substitute for my judgement as a supervisor? No. It keeps every student's milestones visible so you can supervise them as the distinct projects they are. You keep the call on what each milestone requires.
If you run supervision across a portfolio of students, the Thesis Studio explanation walks through the workflow, and the features page shows how it fits the rest of Lectimax. New accounts get 200 free credits (limited-time promo) to try it.